Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jetse de Vries's avatar

I suspect that the writers who got their novel in early have a geat advantage in visibility, as they have already gained quite a few votes and comments, which will subsequently attract more readers.

I submitted my entry of February 1, and it took until February 21 until it was up, just before the submission closing deadline. I tagged my novel as both “Fantasy” and “Historical”. After the deadline closed, I counted 275 novels in the “Historical” tag alone, and I suspect there may well be more than one thousand entries under the “Fantasy” tag.

According to the latest statistics I saw—today Sunday March 8—there were some 11,039 registered readers, of which 45.95% were (or have been) active. Simple mathematics tells us this means 5072 active readers.

—If there are 1,000 novels in the competition and 5,000 active readers, then theoretically every novel can have 5 reads of their sample chapters—on average.

—If there are 2,000 novels in the competition, this number decreases to 2.5.

However, this is if one reader only reads one set of sample chapters. If they read more, the number goes up.

So it should be possible that every entry eventually gets, say 10 reads (of their sample chapters). However, what I see is that some novels accumulate well above 100 reads, while the majority struggles to get more than 1 or 2. It’s very lopsided.

Also, when I explore the entries, it seems that those with at least 10 comments or more show up on top, while those with 0 only come into view after a lot of scrolling. So once you’re down, you seem to stay down.

So what to do about it in a future Libraro Prize (if that happens)?

I’d propose keep all the blurbs, stories about the story and sample chapters invisible to the readers until all of the entries have been set up.

Then—when everybody’s entry is ready—open it up to readers. Early entrants than have no unfair advantage.

Also, maybe add a rating system—one to five stars, or 1 to 10 points—in there, so that you get not only the most read ones, but also the ones with the highest ratings (as long as a minimum amount of ratings has been reached: one rating is not representative enough).

Finally, only allow comments from readers, not from participating writers (who now try to entice each other to mutually comment), as this gives a false impression of real interest.

Otherwise it’ll become a prize for best networker and self-promoter. We’ll see later in the year.

Donna Fisher's avatar

Interested to know what your thoughts are on Libraro…I’ve just written an article about my experience on it.

No posts

Ready for more?